May 23, 2013: The San Diego Union-Tribune online published an editorial this morning by State Senator Leland Yee (D-San Mateo-San Francisco); Yee holds a doctorate in child psychology. In January, he introduced Senate Bill 61 to address the issue of juveniles in solitary confinement. It is being heard today in the Senate Appropriations Committee. Below, an edited version of Yee's editorial:
... the mind of a juvenile is still developing ...Young people are still able to learn from their mistakes and turn their lives around... Yet many policies commonplace in the juvenile justice system make rehabilitation less likely. One such policy is the use of solitary confinement on children.
At left, a photo by Richard Ross, whose latest project is "Suitable Placement: Juvenile Justice in America." This is from the Harrison County Juvenile Detention Center in Biloxi, Mississippi.
... I have introduced Senate Bill 61 to set uniform limits on the use of solitary confinement for kids...
Throughout ..California, minors in the juvenile justice system are being held in solitary confinement. Some of those kids spend 23 hours a day in a small box with no human contact, being allowed only a brief break to bathe and stretch their legs. Nationally, over half of youth who committed suicide while incarcerated were in solitary confinement, and 62 percent had a history of being placed there. The United Nations has called for a complete ban on inflicting this punishment on juveniles as it has been repeatedly proven to increase risk of suicide, worsen mental health, and make those subjected to it more likely to reoffend upon release. Despite all this, the practice is rampant. ... Six states — Connecticut, Arizona, Maine, Oklahoma, West Virginia and Alaska — have already banned the practice of putting juveniles in solitary for punitive reasons. Separation from other people for extended periods of time can easily result in disorientation and hallucinations, depression, anxiety, psychosis, and self-harm. Why would our state have a policy that inflicts or worsens mental illness?
Currently, there is no standard definition for solitary confinement in the juvenile justice system. The offense that can land a minor in solitary, the length of the stay, and the follow-up conducted by staff all vary from facility to facility. In addition, county reporting standards are nearly nonexistent; making it difficult to adequately understand the impact solitary confinement has on individual children. A uniform policy throughout the state will help to curb abuses of this practice...
Continuing this practice costs the public far more in the long run, as a lifetime of mental illness or recidivism that results in further jail time will be at the taxpayer’s expense. Considering it costs an average of $47,000 a year to incarcerate an inmate in California, this practice is too expensive both fiscally and morally for our state to afford.